Go Back
Halloween Witch Finger cookies - 12

Halloween Witch Finger Cookies

These witch finger cookies are sugar cookies dipped in strawberry crush. Recipe Author: Madhushree
Cook Time 2 hrs
Total Time 2 hrs
Course Cakes and Bakes
Servings 36 nos


  • 2 cups All purpose flour
  • 1 cup Caster sugar
  • 1/2 cup Butter
  • 2 tsp vanilla essence
  • 1 no Egg
  • 1 tsp baking powder
  • 36 nos almonds
  • 1 tbsp red liquid food colour see notes
  • 3 tbsp strawberry/ raspberry crush see notes


  • In a bowl, take the food colour and dip the almonds in the food colour. Let the almonds soak the colour for sometime.
  • In a mixing bowl, cream the butter and sugar. Then crack one egg into it and whisk. The egg should be at room temperature. Add the vanilla essence and continue whisking for a minute or so till the egg completely incorporates with the butter sugar mixture.
  • Now sift in the flour along with baking powder and beat it one more time. I have used an electic hand mixer for the process.
  • Finally you will have to use your hands to bring the dough together and knead it into a smooth ball. Cut the dough in two parts and cover them both in cling films. (see notes)
  • Turn on your oven to 160 degree c and prepare a baking tray with a cookie sheet or parchment paper.
  • In a separate plate, place a kitchen towel and using a forcep, take the almonds out and spread them on the kitchen towel.
  • Now take one dough and scoop out little more than a tbsp of dough from it. Roll the dough into a cylinder in the palm of your hand (shown in a picture above). One end should be narrower than the other. It should be approximately 4 to 4.5 inches long and keep them as thin as possible.
  • Place the finger on the cookie sheet. Take one almond and place it at the narrower end to make the finger nail. Gently press the almond on the dough to set it in.
  • Now using you little finger, make two dents in the cylinder, like shown in a picture above. This will give you the mound for the knuckles. Using the end of the knife, make many horizontal lines on the mounds to make the knuckles.
  • While doing so, keep shaping the finger with your other hand. Repeat the process till you finish the dough.
  • Keep a distance of 1/2 an inch between each finger while placing them on the cookie sheet.
  • Bake them in the oven for about 12 - 15 minutes. You have to watch them like a hawk so that the bottom doesn't burn. Just as you see the bottom turning golden, take the cookies out and transfer the witch fingers on a wire rack to cool them down.
  • Like all cookies, they are soft when they come out of the oven. Once cooled down, the witch fingers harden on the outside.
  • Finally dip the other ends of the witch fingers in strawberry crush and place them on a tray before serving. The witch fingers can be stored in air tight container for a few days.
  • You can also store the dough in the refrigerator for a couple of days and bring it to room temperature before rolling out.


  1. You can dip the almonds in gel food colour or liquid food colour. In case you don't want, you can leave the almonds as it is. Witches can have dirty brown finger nails.
  2. For colouring of the stubs, you can use either of the berry crushes or take some jam and heat it in a pan. Alternately, you can also use food colour for the same instead of the jam. But kids tend to love the jam/crush.
  3. I had cut the dough into two since the it takes quite sometime to make each finger. I made the fingers over two days. So I had kept one of the dough in the refrigerator.
  4. I also noticed that if you leave the dough without the cling film while rolling out, the dough tends to dry out. So best it to keep the cling film on between rolling out each finger.
  5. You need to roll the fingers as thin as possible (without breaking) since they expand a little bit in the oven.
  6. You can get creative and use green colour for the cookie dough too to make green fingers.